What does an umbrella policy actually pay for? The best answer isn't a definition. It's a list of the kinds of claims families face. A personal umbrella adds liability coverage above your home and auto policies, and the claims that reach it are rarely dramatic. They start with an ordinary afternoon: a babysitting job, a backyard pool, a teenager borrowing the car.
The short version: A personal umbrella pays liability claims above your home and auto limits, including libel and slander claims your homeowners policy usually doesn't cover. The claims that reach it start in ordinary places: a teenager's babysitting job, an online post, a backyard pool, a party or a rental property.
The ten examples below come from umbrella claim examples used in insurance industry training. They are not J. Jacobs & Associates clients, they aren't all from Michigan, and we've retold them in our own words. Dollar amounts are as reported in that material. What each one teaches about coverage is what matters.
When your kids are the reason
- The babysitting job. A teenage babysitter left a five-month-old in a walker. The infant toppled over and suffered brain damage. The parents sued the teenager and her parents, and the court awarded $11,000,000. A family's liability coverage can follow a teenager's part-time job.
- The online posts. A couple's daughter posted false, disparaging statements about a teacher online. The teacher sued the student's parents for personal injury, and $750,000 was paid. This is the one most families don't see coming: libel and slander are "personal injury," which a standard homeowners policy doesn't cover unless you add it by endorsement. Personal umbrellas generally include it, although the standard umbrella form excludes statements the insured knew were false, so coverage for the person who posted isn't automatic.
- The teen driver. An 18-year-old lost control of his parents' car and hit a tree. His girlfriend, a 19-year-old college student, spent more than a month in the hospital with fractures and internal injuries and was left with drop foot in her right foot. The umbrella paid its full limit.
A note on that last one for Michigan drivers: under no-fault, an injured passenger's medical bills are normally paid by personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, usually from her own household's policy. But a seriously injured person can still sue an at-fault driver for pain and suffering and for economic losses beyond what PIP pays. Those lawsuits are where an umbrella earns its keep. See adding a teen driver in Michigan.
When your property is the reason
- The pool. A 28-year-old engineer dove into a friend's above-ground pool, hit the bottom and became quadriplegic. He sued the homeowner and the pool manufacturer. The court found the homeowner 60% responsible and awarded $10,000,000. Pools, trampolines and dogs are classic umbrella exposures; see trampolines, pools and dogs.
- The hillside you inherited. A previous owner had covered a hillside with concrete to stop erosion. About five feet of the concrete fell onto the neighbor's property and knocked the neighbor's house off its foundation. The claim settled for $970,000. You can be responsible for a condition you didn't create.
- The rental furnace. A tenant claimed permanent brain damage from carbon monoxide caused by a faulty furnace and demanded $750,000. In Michigan, landlords should know that a personal umbrella generally covers a rental home only to the extent the underlying policy on that property provides liability coverage. Every rental has to be on your underlying insurance. See our landlord insurance guide.
When a gathering is the reason
- The paintball game. A homeowner let her children and their friends play paintball in a large back yard. The kids were experienced and knew the rules, including wearing headgear at all times. One participant took off her headgear as she was leaving the field, to hear someone calling her name, and was hit in the eye. The claim settled for $475,000.
- The beach bonfire. A family hosted a beach party for their daughter. A guest threw what looked like an empty, discarded propane tank into the bonfire, and it exploded, seriously injuring several guests. A $20,000,000 claim alleged the hosts failed to supervise the party.
- The teen party. A couple hosted a party for teens and didn't provide alcohol, but guests brought it. A guest was badly hurt in a car crash after leaving, and the case went to a state supreme court. Both the homeowners and umbrella policies responded. Michigan law isn't the same as that state's: here, liability has generally turned on whether the host actually furnished the alcohol, and knowingly allowing minors to drink is a crime. But the lesson holds. Even a defensible claim can take years and serious money to defend. See hosting a holiday party in Michigan.
When coaching is the reason
- The coach. A teenage softball player filed a $700,000 lawsuit against her former coach, alleging the coach's teaching style ruined her chance at an athletic scholarship. The material doesn't say whether the coach was paid or how the claim ended. Unpaid civic activity is an exception to the business exclusion in the standard personal umbrella form, but the policy still pays only for bodily injury, property damage or personal injury, and a paid coach is running a business.
What these claims have in common
- None of them started with someone setting out to hurt anyone. They involved ordinary families, ordinary property and ordinary kids.
- All of them exceeded a typical $300,000 or $500,000 home or auto liability limit, some many times over.
- Two came from exposures a base home policy doesn't cover without an endorsement or a separate policy: online statements and a rental.
- Defense costs alone can be enormous. An umbrella typically adds defense when underlying limits run out or don't apply.
For limits, requirements and what an umbrella costs, see Michigan umbrella insurance: who needs it and umbrella underlying limit requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a personal umbrella policy cover?
It pays liability claims above your home and auto policy limits: bodily injury and property damage you're responsible for, plus "personal injury" such as libel, slander and invasion of privacy. It also adds legal defense when underlying limits are exhausted or don't apply. Business activities, professional services and intentional acts are excluded.
Does umbrella insurance cover social media posts?
Usually, if the claim is libel, slander or invasion of privacy. Personal umbrellas commonly include "personal injury" coverage for statements published in any form, including online. A standard homeowners policy doesn't include it unless you add a personal injury endorsement.
Does an umbrella cover my rental property in Michigan?
Generally only to the extent your underlying insurance on that rental provides liability coverage. Every rental property needs its own liability coverage that meets the umbrella's requirements, or the umbrella won't respond.
Does a personal umbrella cover volunteer coaching?
It can, for injury claims arising from unpaid coaching, which the standard form treats as a civic activity rather than a business. Paid coaching is a business, and a claim that isn't for bodily injury, property damage or personal injury may not be covered at all. Confirm the wording on your carrier's form.
How much umbrella coverage do I need?
Enough to protect your assets and future income. The claims above show why $1,000,000 is a floor rather than a ceiling for many Michigan homeowners, especially those with teen drivers, pools, rentals or significant savings.
Sources
- ISO Homeowners 3 form HO 00 03 05 11 (filed copy, Maine Bureau of Insurance)
- Furnishing alcohol to minors, MCL 436.1701
- Allowing minors to drink at a gathering, MCL 750.141a
The bottom line
The claims that reach an umbrella don't look dangerous in advance. A babysitting job, a post, a pool, a hillside. An umbrella turns those once-in-a-lifetime events into an insurance problem instead of a financial one.
J. Jacobs & Associates is an independent agency in Lake Orion that has insured Michigan families since 1981. We represent more than twenty carriers, so we can match an umbrella to your home, auto, rentals and boats and make sure the underlying limits line up. Send us your current declarations pages and we'll show you how much protection you have and what more would cost. Call (248) 693-6455, visit our umbrella insurance page or start a quote.
