Cyber insurance isn't a single coverage. It's a bundle of separate insuring agreements, each with its own limit, sublimit and deductible, and two policies both labeled "cyber" can cover very different things. Many Michigan businesses believe they're covered because they see the word cyber on a declarations page. When we look closer, they often own a small endorsement on their package policy, or a cyber policy with a strong headline limit and a small sublimit on the one loss that actually hits them.
The short version: Cyber insurance is a bundle of separate coverages: your own costs (breach response, business interruption, ransomware), claims against you (privacy liability, regulatory penalties), and stolen funds (funds transfer fraud and social engineering, often under a small sublimit). Check each one's limit on your declarations page, and coordinate cyber with your crime policy.
Below are the types of cyber coverage, what each one pays for, and the gaps we see most often when we review a business's current program.
Where your cyber coverage may be coming from
- An endorsement on your business owner's or package policy. Convenient, but these limits are usually far smaller than a standalone policy's, and they may cover only part of the list below. Some recent package-policy cyber endorsements are liability-only and pay nothing toward your own costs, and some of those cover only injury or property damage, not a data breach.
- A standalone cyber policy. The broadest option, built from the coverage parts below. The quality depends on which parts are included and at what limits.
- A commercial crime policy. Crime coverage can pay for some electronic theft of funds, and it's often where social engineering coverage lives. It overlaps with cyber in confusing ways, covered below.
First-party cyber coverage: your own losses
- Breach response. Forensic investigators, a breach attorney (often called a breach coach), notification letters, call centers, credit monitoring for affected people, and public relations help.
- Business interruption. Lost income and extra expense while your systems are down. Two details decide whether it pays. The waiting period is the hours of downtime you absorb first. The trigger is whether only a security failure (an attack) counts, or a system failure (an outage with no attack behind it) counts too. The July 2024 CrowdStrike outage was a faulty software update, not an attack, so security-failure-only policies may not have responded.
- Dependent business interruption. Lost income when a vendor you rely on, such as a cloud host, payroll processor or software platform, goes down. Not every policy includes it, and some cover only named vendors or only IT vendors.
- Data restoration. The cost to restore or recreate data and software damaged in an attack.
- Cyber extortion and ransomware. Negotiators, response costs and, where the policy and the law allow, the ransom. Ransomware showed up in 88% of breaches at small and mid-sized organizations in Verizon's 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report.
- Hardware replacement ("bricking"). Replacing computers and devices that an attack has made unusable even though they aren't physically damaged. Often a separate coverage part, sometimes missing.
- Betterment. Some policies pay to restore systems with current, more secure versions instead of rebuilding the same vulnerable setup.
- Reputational harm. Lost profit from customers who leave after a publicized breach. Often available only by endorsement.
Third-party cyber coverage: claims against you
- Network security and privacy liability. Defense and damages when customers, patients or business partners sue over their data being exposed, or over malware that spread from your systems to theirs.
- Regulatory defense and penalties. Responding to regulators after a breach, and fines and penalties where insurable. As of November 2026, Michigan's Identity Theft Protection Act (MCL 445.72) requires notice to affected Michigan residents without unreasonable delay when a breach is likely to cause substantial loss, injury or identity theft. If more than 1,000 residents are notified, the national credit reporting agencies must be told too. Knowingly failing to notify can bring a civil fine of up to $250 per failure, capped at $750,000 per breach. A bill that would add Attorney General notice and security requirements passed the Michigan Senate in 2025 and was still pending in the House when we wrote this.
- Payment card (PCI) fines and assessments. If you take credit cards, a breach can bring contractual fines and assessments from the card brands through your processor. Ordinary liability coverage typically won't pay those; this coverage part does.
- Media liability. Claims over content you publish online, such as copyright or trademark infringement and defamation on your website or social accounts.
Cyber crime coverage: when money leaves the account
This is where many programs are thinnest. Verizon's 2026 report found a human element in 45% of breaches at small and mid-sized organizations, and tricking an employee into sending money is one of the most direct ways that plays out.
- Funds transfer fraud. A criminal gets into your systems or your bank account and moves money out without your authorization.
- Social engineering (fraudulent instruction). An employee is tricked into sending the money: a spoofed email from the "owner," a vendor's "new bank account," a fake invoice. Because your employee made the transfer, many policies treat it differently from hacking. Sublimits of $250,000 or less are often seen in both cyber and crime policies, even when the policy's main limit is $1 million or more.
- Invoice manipulation. A criminal gets into your systems and alters your invoices, so customers pay the criminal instead of you.
- Telecommunications fraud. Someone hijacks your phone system and runs up toll charges.
- Utility fraud or cryptojacking. Someone uses your computing power, for example to mine cryptocurrency, and your utility or cloud bill jumps.
Many cyber policies also attach a verification condition to social engineering coverage: you must confirm any change to payment instructions by a separate phone call or method. If your staff skips the call-back, the claim can be denied. If your policy has that condition, it belongs in your accounts payable procedures, in writing.
Cyber policy or crime policy? Who pays when an employee wires money
Courts have split on whether a traditional crime policy's computer fraud coverage pays when an employee is tricked into sending a wire. A Michigan tool manufacturer, American Tooling Center, won coverage in the federal Sixth Circuit in 2018 after wiring about $834,000 to a criminal impersonating a vendor by email. The court held that computer fraud coverage isn't limited to hacking. Two years earlier, the Fifth Circuit reached the opposite result after Apache Corporation sent roughly $7 million to a criminal's account (it recovered much of it and claimed about $2.4 million), calling the email incidental to an authorized transfer.
Since 2015, ISO's commercial crime forms have combined computer fraud and funds transfer fraud into one insuring agreement, and the 2022 edition made fraudulent impersonation a separate, optional coverage. Insurers have increasingly written social engineering in or out explicitly. The practical lesson: don't assume either policy covers a tricked employee. Find the words "social engineering," "fraudulent impersonation" or "fraudulent instruction" on a declarations page, with a limit next to them, and make sure your cyber and crime policies don't each assume the other one has it.
Conditions and exclusions that sink cyber claims
- Your application. Underwriters ask detailed questions about multi-factor authentication, backups and endpoint protection. In 2022, a federal court in Illinois rescinded an Illinois company's cyber policy by agreement after a ransomware attack, because the application said multi-factor authentication protected systems where it was actually only on the firewall. Answer the application accurately, and tell us when your controls change.
- War and state-backed attack exclusions. Since March 2023, Lloyd's has required standalone cyber policies written in its market to exclude war and the most severe state-backed cyber attacks, with varying carve-backs. Read how your policy defines them.
- Claims-made timing. Most cyber liability is claims-made, with a retroactive date. Switching carriers carelessly can leave a gap for incidents that started before the switch.
- Required controls. Missing multi-factor authentication, endpoint detection or tested offline backups can mean higher premiums, lower limits or no offer at all.
How to check what you actually bought
- Pull the declarations pages for your cyber policy, any cyber endorsement on your package policy, and your crime policy.
- List every insuring agreement with its limit, sublimit and retention. If a coverage part above isn't on the list, assume you don't have it.
- Check the social engineering limit against the largest payment your business routinely sends.
- Check the business interruption trigger and waiting period, and whether vendor outages are covered.
- Reread your last application and confirm the security controls it describes are still true.
For background on why businesses need cyber coverage at all, see does your Michigan business need cyber insurance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main types of cyber insurance coverage?
First-party coverage pays your own costs: breach response, business interruption, data restoration, ransomware and hardware replacement. Third-party coverage pays claims against you: privacy and network security liability, regulatory actions, payment card assessments and media liability. Cyber crime coverage pays for stolen funds, including social engineering losses, often under a separate sublimit.
Does cyber insurance cover an employee who was tricked into wiring money?
Only if the policy includes social engineering or fraudulent instruction coverage, and often only up to a sublimit, commonly $250,000 or less. Some policies require a call-back verification of payment changes as a condition of coverage. Some businesses carry it on their crime policy instead.
Is the cyber coverage on my business owner's policy enough?
Usually not for an established business. Package-policy cyber endorsements typically carry small limits and may cover only some of the coverage parts, and some are liability-only. Compare each coverage part and limit against a standalone cyber policy.
Does Michigan require businesses to report data breaches?
Yes. Michigan's Identity Theft Protection Act requires a business that owns or licenses personal data to notify affected Michigan residents without unreasonable delay, unless it determines the breach isn't likely to cause substantial loss, injury or identity theft. Knowingly failing to notify can bring civil fines of up to $250 per failure, capped at $750,000 per breach.
Does cyber insurance cover outages that aren't cyber attacks?
Only if the business interruption coverage includes system failure, not just security failure. An outage from a bad software update, like the 2024 CrowdStrike event, may not be covered under a security-failure-only trigger.
Sources
- Michigan Identity Theft Protection Act, MCL 445.72
- Verizon 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report, executive summary
- American Tooling Center v Travelers (6th Cir 2018)
- Apache Corp v Great American Insurance (5th Cir 2016)
- Insurance Journal: cyber-enabled fraud coverage (June 2026)
- Lockton: Travelers v ICS and cyber application accuracy
The bottom line
A cyber program is only as good as its weakest coverage part, and the weak part is usually the one that pays when money leaves your account. Two businesses can both say "we have cyber" and be covered for completely different losses.
We work best with established Michigan businesses — payroll on the books, real customer data or payment volume, and a few years of loss history. Send us the declarations pages for your cyber, crime and package policies, your most recent cyber application and your loss runs, and we'll lay out, coverage part by coverage part, what you bought and what you didn't before we talk about price. J. Jacobs & Associates has insured Michigan businesses since 1981, and as an independent agency representing more than twenty carriers, we can coordinate your cyber and crime coverage so the gaps don't fall between them. Call (248) 693-6455 or visit our cyber liability insurance page.
