Are you liable if someone slips on your icy driveway in Michigan? It depends on who fell and why they were there. The Michigan Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Kandil-Elsayed v F & E Oil changed how "open and obvious" hazards like snow and ice are handled, and plaintiffs' attorneys took notice. For homeowners, the change matters most for people on your property for a business purpose. For social guests, the rules are more forgiving. Either way, winter falls are a familiar source of homeowner liability claims.
The short version: Since the Michigan Supreme Court's 2023 Kandil-Elsayed decision, an obvious hazard like snow or ice no longer ends a slip-and-fall case automatically for business visitors; it's weighed in fault instead. Social guests are still owed a more limited duty, and homeowners generally aren't liable for natural snow on the public sidewalk unless they make it worse.
What Kandil-Elsayed changed
For two decades, Michigan property owners could often get slip-and-fall cases dismissed early by arguing the hazard was "open and obvious," meaning a reasonable person would have seen it. Under the old rule, that meant the owner owed no duty at all, with narrow exceptions. In July 2023, the Michigan Supreme Court overruled that approach. Now, whether a hazard was open and obvious is weighed when deciding whether the owner acted reasonably and how fault is split between the owner and the person who fell.
The practical result: fewer cases end early and more go to a jury or settle. The injured person's own share of fault reduces what they can recover, and a person found more than 50% at fault can't recover pain-and-suffering damages at all. The Court also revived an older rule that owners must take reasonable measures, within a reasonable time after snow and ice accumulate, to protect invitees. That doesn't mean clearing during every storm.
Who fell matters: guests vs. business visitors
- Social guests. Friends and family visiting socially are generally "licensees" in Michigan. A homeowner's duty to them is to warn of hidden dangers the homeowner knows about or has reason to know about, if the guest doesn't. There's no general duty to inspect the property or make it safe for social guests. In a 2024 case involving a social guest who fell on a friend's icy back steps, the Court of Appeals held that Kandil-Elsayed didn't change that limited duty. Visible snow and ice is rarely a hidden danger. That decision is unpublished, so it isn't binding, but it's directly on point.
- Business visitors. People on your property for a business purpose, such as a contractor you hired, can be "invitees," owed reasonable care. That's where Kandil-Elsayed matters most for homeowners.
- Clients of a home business. If customers come to your home for your business, you have invitee exposure, and your homeowners policy may exclude business-related injuries. See home-based business insurance.
The public sidewalk in front of your house
Michigan courts have generally held that homeowners have no duty to keep the public sidewalk next to their property free of natural snow and ice. Many cities have ordinances requiring owners to clear sidewalks within a set time, but those are generally enforced with fines and city clearing at the owner's expense, not automatic liability for a fall.
Two exceptions matter. You can become responsible if your snow removal makes the hazard worse, or if you create an unnatural accumulation, for example a downspout or sump line that drains across the sidewalk and freezes. Fix drainage before winter, and don't pile snow where meltwater refreezes across a walk.
Hiring a plow service doesn't shift your responsibility
The Michigan Supreme Court has held that a snow removal contractor that simply fails to plow or salt as its contract required doesn't owe a duty to a third party who slips. The person who fell generally looks to the property owner, not the plow company, although a contractor can still be liable if its own work creates a new hazard. Still, hire a contractor who carries general liability insurance, ask for a certificate of insurance, and use a written agreement. See our guide to snow removal contractor insurance.
Is a change in the law coming?
House Bill 4582, which would restore much of the old open and obvious rule for invitees, passed the Michigan House in March 2026 and was sent to a Senate committee. As of mid-November 2026, it hasn't become law. For now, Kandil-Elsayed controls.
How your insurance responds
- Personal liability coverage on your homeowners policy pays damages you're legally responsible for and your legal defense, up to your limit.
- Medical payments to others pays an injured visitor's medical bills regardless of fault, usually at a modest limit. It often resolves small falls quickly.
- A personal umbrella adds liability coverage above your home policy. A fall that causes a serious head or spinal injury can exceed a home liability limit. See umbrella claim examples.
- Business visitors to a home business may need a commercial policy or endorsement; don't assume your homeowners policy covers them.
A winter checklist for Michigan homeowners
- Clear and salt walks and steps within a reasonable time after snow stops, and before guests or contractors arrive.
- Fix drainage that sends water across walks or the driveway.
- Light entries and steps and repair loose railings.
- Warn people about hazards you know or have reason to know about that aren't obvious, like black ice by the garage.
- Get a certificate of insurance from your plow contractor.
- Check your liability limit and consider an umbrella.
Frequently Asked Questions
Am I liable if someone slips on ice at my house in Michigan?
It depends on who they are and why they were there. Social guests are owed a limited duty, mainly a warning about hidden dangers you know or have reason to know about. People there for a business purpose can be owed reasonable care. After Kandil-Elsayed, an obvious hazard is weighed in fault rather than ending the case automatically.
What did Kandil-Elsayed v F & E Oil decide?
In July 2023, the Michigan Supreme Court held that whether a hazard is open and obvious is no longer a question of whether the owner owed any duty. It's considered when deciding whether the owner acted reasonably and how fault is shared, which makes early dismissals of slip-and-fall cases less common.
Do I have to shovel the public sidewalk in front of my house in Michigan?
Many cities require it by ordinance, enforced with fines and cleanup charges. Michigan courts have generally held that homeowners don't owe pedestrians a duty to clear natural accumulations from public sidewalks, unless the homeowner makes the hazard worse or creates an unnatural accumulation.
Does homeowners insurance cover a slip and fall on my property?
Generally yes, if you're found legally responsible, under personal liability coverage, and medical payments coverage can pay smaller injuries regardless of fault. Injuries tied to business activities on your property may be excluded.
Sources
- Kandil-Elsayed v F & E Oil (Mich 2023)
- Hassen v Hopson (Mich App 2024, unpublished)
- Comparative fault and noneconomic damages, MCL 600.2959
- House Bill 4582 of 2025
The bottom line
Michigan law still gives homeowners real protection when social guests fall on visible snow and ice, but Kandil-Elsayed made slip-and-fall claims harder to dismiss, especially for people on your property for business. Good snow habits prevent a lot of falls. The right liability limits handle the rest.
J. Jacobs & Associates is an independent agency in Lake Orion that has insured Michigan homes since 1981. We represent more than twenty carriers, so we can compare liability limits, medical payments coverage and umbrella options and show you what better protection costs. Call (248) 693-6455, visit our Michigan home insurance page or start a quote.
