Michigan Printer, Direct Mail and Advertising Agency Insurance: The Coverage That Is Turned Off for You

Running a print shop, mail house or agency in southeast Michigan? Have us review your program →

Michigan printer and advertising agency insurance contains one of the most counterintuitive provisions in commercial insurance, and almost nobody in the industry has had it explained to them. The section of a general liability policy that covers libel, disparagement, invasion of privacy and copyright infringement in an advertisement — the section that reads like it was drafted specifically for an ad agency — is the section the form turns off when the insured's business is advertising. If you print, mail or create advertising for a living, that sentence is the whole reason to read this.

The media business exclusion, and what survives it

Coverage B of the standard commercial general liability form insures "personal and advertising injury," which the form defines as a closed list of seven offenses:

• false arrest, detention or imprisonment;
• malicious prosecution;
• wrongful eviction from, wrongful entry into, or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a room, dwelling or premises a person occupies, committed by or on behalf of its owner, landlord or lessor;
• publication of material that slanders or libels a person or organization, or disparages their goods, products or services;
• publication of material that violates a person's right of privacy;
• the use of another's advertising idea in your advertisement; and
• infringing upon another's copyright, trade dress or slogan in your advertisement.

Look at the last four. Those are, more or less, the complete list of ways an advertising agency gets sued for doing its job.

Now read the exclusion. Coverage B excludes personal and advertising injury committed by an insured whose business is (1) advertising, broadcasting, publishing or telecasting; (2) designing or determining content of websites for others; or (3) an internet search, access, content or service provider. The exclusion carves back only the first three offenses on that list — false arrest, malicious prosecution and wrongful eviction.

Put plainly: on the standard unendorsed form, the four offenses that describe an advertising agency's actual exposure are removed, and the three that have nothing to do with advertising are kept. The exclusion is not a carrier being difficult. It is the form telling you this exposure belongs in a different policy.

Three details that change who this reaches:

• Prong (2) catches modern agencies independently. An agency that builds client websites is excluded under the web-design prong whether or not anyone calls it an advertising business.
• Printers and mail houses generally are not caught — but not for the reason usually given. The exclusion ends with a saving clause: placing frames, borders or links, or advertising, for you or others anywhere on the Internet, is not by itself the business of advertising, broadcasting, publishing or telecasting. Read that carefully. It is an internet-specific clause, not a general rule that running your own marketing keeps you out. What actually keeps a commercial printer out is that its business is printing, not advertising, broadcasting, publishing or telecasting — a question of fact about how your operation is described. A shop that markets itself as a "publisher" has handed a carrier an argument.
• A separate exclusion handles intellectual property: infringement of copyright, patent, trademark, trade secret or other intellectual property rights is excluded, with one carve-back — infringement of copyright, trade dress or slogan in your own advertisement survives. Note what that leaves out. Patent, trademark and trade secret are gone outright, and trade secret matters more than printers expect once you are holding a client's lists and campaign data. A printer sued for reproducing a client's infringing artwork is not advertising anything of its own. That is a real limit, and it is a common claim.

The honest caveat: this is how the unendorsed standard form is built. Whether a particular insured is "an insured whose business is advertising" is itself litigated, and carriers sometimes buy the exclusion back or write hybrid forms. The analysis starts here. It does not end here.

What answers it instead

Media liability — sometimes sold as advertisers professional liability or multimedia liability — is the product built for this. It is a nonstandard line: there is no single industry form the way there is for a liability policy, so wordings, named perils and definitions differ materially between carriers. That is exactly why the form matters more here than the price.

One clarification, because a knowledgeable reader will raise it: ISO does publish a miscellaneous professional liability program. That is a general professional liability chassis, not a media liability form. True media and advertisers liability remains carrier-drafted.

The botched run: excluded twice, and not by accident

You print 40,000 catalogs and the client's phone number is wrong on every one. Nobody is hurt. Nothing is physically damaged. You have 40,000 pieces of expensive wastepaper and a client who wants them redone by Thursday.

A liability policy is not built for that, and it fails in three places, in this order:

• The insuring agreement first. The policy pays for property damage caused by an occurrence. Nothing was physically injured and nothing else lost its use — the catalogs are just wrong. The gap starts at the trigger, not at an exclusion, and that distinction matters because a trigger failure is not something an endorsement fixes.
• Exclusion k, Damage To Your Product, removes property damage to your own product arising out of it.
• Exclusion m, Damage To Impaired Property Or Property Not Physically Injured, removes damage to property that has not been physically injured when the cause is a defect in your product or work, or a delay or failure to perform a contract on its terms — with a carve-back for loss of use of other property caused by sudden and accidental physical injury to your work after it has been put to its intended use.

Between them, the paper, the ink, the press time and the do-over are not a general liability claim. They are a business problem — and if you want that insured, the product is printers errors and omissions, which carriers do write, sometimes with an express "correction of work" extension. That extension is the piece that actually funds the reprint.

Worth saying so the post is not fear-selling: the liability policy is not useless to a printer. A mislabeled product warning that hurts someone, a chemical release at the plant, a delivery accident — all ordinary liability territory. The gap is confined to the quality of the printed work itself and its economic consequences.

The press is not covered by your property policy

Commercial property policies cover external causes of loss. The standard causes-of-loss form excludes "mechanical breakdown, including rupture or bursting caused by centrifugal force" — with a narrow exception for resulting elevator collision, which is no help to a pressroom.

When a press drive fails or a folder or bindery line goes down, that exclusion is why the property policy is not the answer — and a separate exclusion for artificially generated electrical current handles the control cabinet that takes a surge. Equipment breakdown coverage is, and written properly it responds both to the damage to the equipment and to the income lost while the press is down plus the extra expense of buying press time elsewhere to keep a customer supplied. For a shop where one press is a meaningful share of capacity, that time-element piece is the point of the purchase. Our guide to Michigan business interruption insurance covers how those periods are measured.

The mail house problem: you are holding data

A direct mail operation holds customer lists. That is personally identifiable information sitting on your servers, belonging to somebody else, and it creates two exposures a liability policy handles badly.

First, violation of a person's right of privacy is on the personal and advertising injury list — but Coverage B carries an exclusion for recording and distribution of material or information in violation of law, which names the TCPA, CAN-SPAM and FCRA/FACTA and then adds a catch-all reaching any statute that "addresses, prohibits, or limits the printing, dissemination, disposal, collecting, recording, sending, transmitting, communicating or distribution of material or information." For a direct mail company, that catch-all is arguably the most consequential sentence in Coverage B.

Second, the standard form excludes damages arising out of loss of, damage to, corruption of or inability to access electronic data, and states that electronic data is not tangible property. A breach of your mailing lists is not a property damage claim.

Both roads lead to the same place: cyber liability, with first-party breach response and third-party liability, is not optional for a business whose inventory is other people's customer data.

How Michigan classifies you for workers' comp

Michigan is not an NCCI state — the Compensation Advisory Organization of Michigan maintains Michigan's own classification manual. Three structural facts matter here.

Mail houses have their own code. Michigan's Code 8800, Addressing or Mailing Company, covers concerns that prepare mailing lists and arrange for or engage in mailing and addressing against those lists, including envelope stuffing. The manual is emphatic about the trap: all of those operations belong in 8800 even though they may appear to be clerical-type functions, and the clerical code cannot be used for them, because clerical reaches only office employees who keep books and records for the insured's own business. If your fulfillment floor is sitting in a clerical code, that is an audit finding waiting to happen.

Printing is 4299. The manual's own 8800 entry says printing of letters and advertising materials is separately rated as Code 4299.

There is no advertising agency classification. The advertising-named codes in Michigan's manual describe advertising display service, display service for stores, and outdoor advertising and bill posting — sign and display work, not agency work. An agency office is built from other classifications, and the right ones depend on what your staff actually does. Verify against Michigan's manual with your agent. Our post on Michigan workers' comp class codes explains why the assignment compounds across every payroll dollar.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a general liability policy cover an advertising agency's copyright claim?

On the standard unendorsed form, generally no. Coverage B insures a closed list of offenses including infringement of copyright, trade dress or slogan in your advertisement — but an exclusion for insureds in media and internet type businesses removes those offenses for an insured whose business is advertising, broadcasting, publishing or telecasting, or designing websites for others. Only false arrest, malicious prosecution and wrongful eviction survive. Media or advertisers professional liability is the policy built for the exposure.

Is my print shop caught by the advertising exclusion?

Generally not. The exclusion ends with a saving clause stating that placing frames, borders, links or advertising, for yourself or others, is not by itself the business of advertising. Running your own marketing does not make you an advertising business. A printer's exposure sits elsewhere — in the product and impaired property exclusions, and in reproducing content supplied by clients.

Will insurance pay to reprint a job we got wrong?

Generally not, and the reason starts before the exclusions. A liability policy pays for property damage caused by an occurrence, and misprinted catalogs are not physically injured property. Exclusion k then removes damage to your own product, and exclusion m removes damage to property that has not been physically injured when the cause is a defect in your product or a failure to perform the contract. The reprint is a business risk. Printers errors and omissions is the product that addresses it, and some forms carry an express correction-of-work extension that funds the do-over.

Does commercial property insurance cover a press breakdown?

No. The standard causes-of-loss form excludes mechanical breakdown, including rupture or bursting caused by centrifugal force. Equipment breakdown coverage is what responds to the damage, and when written with time-element coverage it also pays the income lost while the press is down and the extra expense of running the work elsewhere.

Do we need cyber coverage if we only hold mailing lists?

Mailing lists are personally identifiable information belonging to your clients, which is exactly the exposure cyber coverage is built for. The general liability form excludes damages arising out of loss, corruption of or inability to access electronic data and states that electronic data is not tangible property — though that exclusion does not apply to liability for damages because of bodily injury — and Coverage B separately excludes recording and distribution of material or information in violation of law with a broad catch-all reaching statutes governing collecting, sending or distributing information. A list breach falls between those.

The bottom line

For an agency, the question is whether you own a media liability policy, because your general liability policy is switched off for the offenses that define your work. For a printer, it is whether you own errors and omissions with a correction-of-work extension and equipment breakdown with a real time-element limit. For a mail house, it is whether anything responds when the list leaks. All three are visible on your declarations page in about ten minutes.

We work best with established Michigan print, mail and marketing firms — payroll on the books, equipment on the floor or real client contracts, a building you own or lease long-term, and a few years of loss runs. If that is you, send us your current declarations pages, your full schedule of forms and your last two loss runs, and we will show you which exclusions are actually on your policy before we talk about price. As an independent agency representing more than twenty commercial carriers, we can reach the specialty markets that write media and printers E&O. Call (248) 693-6455 or request a review.