4301 S. Baldwin Rd, Lake Orion, MI 48359 (248) 693-6455 Support@jjainsurance.com
Commercial Insurance

What Are Loss Runs? Why Established Michigan Businesses Get Better Commercial Insurance Quotes

What Are Loss Runs? Why Established Michigan Businesses Get Better Commercial Insurance Quotes

Loss runs are the claims history reports your insurance companies keep on your business: every claim, what was paid, what's still reserved and whether it's open or closed. When a Michigan business shops its commercial insurance, the loss runs are the first thing a serious underwriter asks for. Along with years in business, they decide which carriers will quote you and at what price.

The short version: Loss runs are your insurers' reports of every claim on your policies, and commercial underwriters usually want three to five years of them, recently valued. Clean loss runs and a few years in business are what open the door to preferred carriers and their best pricing.

What's in a loss run report

A loss run is a report from each insurer you've had, covering each policy period. It typically shows:

  • Policy details. Your business name, the insurance company, policy number and policy term.
  • Each claim. Date of loss, type of claim and a short description.
  • Paid amounts. What the insurer has already paid.
  • Reserves. What the insurer expects to pay on open claims. Underwriters look at total incurred, which is paid plus reserved, so an open reserve counts like money already spent.
  • Status. Open or closed.
  • The valuation date. The date the figures were current as of. A loss run with no claims should say so ("no reported losses").

How many years underwriters want, and how fresh

Commercial underwriters commonly ask for three to five years of loss runs, for every line being quoted: general liability, property, auto, workers' comp and umbrella. They also want them currently valued, often within 90 days of the quote, and some carriers set shorter windows. A loss run valued last spring may be rejected for a fall renewal.

We found no Michigan statute requiring an insurer to hand you your loss runs within a set number of days. In practice, carriers provide them when asked, but it can take time. Ask for them about 90 days before your renewal, and ask for an updated set if the valuation date will be more than 60 to 90 days old when your quotes go out.

Why years in business matters so much

Three years of clean loss runs tell an underwriter something no application can: how your business actually operates. A brand-new business has no loss history to price, so it's priced as an unknown, often by fewer carriers and at higher rates. One national carrier's contractor underwriting guide, for example, has stated a preference for three years in business, with exceptions for new ventures whose principals have three years of management experience in the same type of business.

That's why established Michigan businesses with a few years of clean loss runs have the most options. Preferred commercial carriers compete hardest for them.

How underwriters read your loss runs

  • Frequency over severity. Several small claims usually worry an underwriter more than one large one, because frequency suggests a pattern. One large, explained loss with a fix in place is often easier to place.
  • Open reserves. A large open reserve counts against you until the claim closes. If a claim settled for less than reserved, make sure the loss run shows it.
  • Trend. Are claims getting fewer and smaller over time? Improvement matters.
  • Claims closed without payment. They still show up. A note explaining them helps.
  • Loss ratio. Losses compared with premium over the period. A business paying $40,000 a year with $5,000 in losses looks very different from one with $60,000 in losses.
  • What changed. New safety programs, a new fleet manager, new hiring practices. Underwriters give you points for corrective action, but only if you tell them.

Workers' comp: your loss runs become your experience mod

In workers' comp, once your premium is large enough to be experience rated, your claims history feeds directly into your experience modification factor. It's calculated in Michigan by the Compensation Advisory Organization of Michigan (CAOM), and it multiplies your premium up or down. An owner can request experience rating data from CAOM with a signed letter of authority on company letterhead. Our post on the Michigan workers' comp experience mod explains how it's calculated and how to bring it down.

How to present your loss runs for the best quote

  1. Gather all of them. Every line of coverage, every carrier, the last five years.
  2. Check them for errors. Claims that belong to another business, reserves on closed claims, duplicates. Ask the carrier to correct them.
  3. Write a short explanation for any significant loss. What happened, what it cost, and what you changed afterward.
  4. Include your safety and risk controls. Written safety programs, driver selection rules, maintenance logs, cameras, training.
  5. Start early. A complete submission 60 to 90 days before renewal gets underwriters' full attention. A rushed one gets their most conservative price.

For more on what moves commercial pricing, see how Michigan businesses earn lower commercial insurance rates.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a loss run report?

A loss run is a report from an insurance company listing every claim on your policies during each policy period, with dates, descriptions, amounts paid, reserves on open claims and claim status. Underwriters use it to price and qualify your business.

How many years of loss runs do I need for a commercial insurance quote?

Most commercial underwriters ask for three to five years of loss runs for each line of coverage being quoted, valued recently, often within 90 days of the quote.

How do I get my loss runs in Michigan?

Ask your current agent or each insurance company directly. We found no Michigan statute requiring insurers to provide them within a set number of days, so ask for them about 90 days before renewal, and request an updated set if they'll be more than 60 to 90 days old when your quotes go out.

Do claims that closed without payment show up on loss runs?

Yes. Claims closed with no payment still appear. In our experience they usually count much less than paid claims, but a short explanation helps an underwriter dismiss them.

Why do businesses with more years in operation pay less for insurance?

Because their loss history shows underwriters how the business actually operates. Several years of clean loss runs let preferred carriers compete for the account, while a new business with no history is priced as an unknown.

Sources

The bottom line

Your loss runs are your business's insurance track record. Clean, complete loss runs and a few years in business are what open the door to preferred commercial carriers and their best pricing.

We work best with established Michigan businesses — payroll on the books, a building you own or a long-term lease, and three to five years of loss runs to show. Send us your current declarations pages and your last five years of loss runs, and we'll tell you how underwriters will read them before we take your account to market. J. Jacobs & Associates has insured Michigan businesses since 1981, and as an independent agency representing more than twenty carriers, we put well-run businesses in front of the preferred carriers that want them. Call (248) 693-6455 or request a commercial review.